KeyCafe SmartBox vs KeyNest Lockers

A side-by-side comparison of the hardware, setup, and daily use

Book a demo
KeyCafe SmartBox

KeyCafe SmartBox

Coverage
N. America, limited EU
Interface
Convoluted, multi-step
Capacity
9, needs extension for more
Pricing
Higher upfront and monthly
Integrations
30+, open API
Access
Navigate through several menus
KeyNest Smart Locker

KeyNest Smart Locker

Coverage
Global, 7,000+ locations
Interface
Simple, one step
Capacity
9, 21 or 39 in one unit
Pricing
Lower upfront and monthly
Integrations
30+, open API
Access
Pick-up-and-go, fob, badge or code
KeyNest vs KeyCafe
Savings
Savings Features Compare
Get in touch
Pricing icon

Calculate your savings

How many keys are you looking to store? info
You only need enough capacity for the maximum number of keys that will be in the locker at one time.

The locker randomises which compartment a key is stored in.

Save over £751 with KeyNest

Save over £1,050 with KeyNest

Save over £850 with KeyNest

Save over £1,250 with KeyNest

Save over £551 with KeyNest

Save over £650 with KeyNest

Save over £351 with KeyNest

Save over £450 with KeyNest

Save over £151 with KeyNest

Save over £49 with KeyCafe

Save over £250 with KeyNest

Save over £249 with KeyCafe

Save over £50 with KeyNest

Save over £449 with KeyCafe

Save over £150 with KeyCafe

KeyCafe
Base + 7 x 42 extension
£8,143
KeyCafe
Base + 1 x 18 extension + 6 x 42 extension
£7,743
KeyCafe
Base + 6 x 42 extension
£7,244
KeyCafe
Base + 1 x 18 extension + 5 x 42 extension
£6,844
KeyCafe
Base + 5 x 42 extension
£6,345
KeyCafe
Base + 1 x 18 extension + 4 x 42 extension
£5,945
KeyCafe
Base + 4 x 42 extension
£5,446
KeyCafe
Base + 1 x 18 extension + 3 x 42 extension
£5,046
KeyCafe
Base + 3 x 42 extension
£4,547
KeyCafe
Base + 1 x 18 extension + 2 x 42 extension
£4,147
KeyCafe
Base + 2 x 42 extension
£3,648
KeyCafe
Base + 1 x 18 extension + 1 x 42 extension
£3,248
KeyCafe
Base + 1 x 42 extension
£2,749
KeyCafe
Base + 1 x 18 extension
£2,349
KeyCafe
Base
£1,850
KeyNest
Large locker + 6 extensions
£8,093
KeyNest
Medium locker + 6 extensions
£7,893
KeyNest
Small locker + 6 extensions
£7,693
KeyNest
Large locker + 5 extensions
£6,994
KeyNest
Medium locker + 5 extensions
£6,794
KeyNest
Small locker + 5 extensions
£6,594
KeyNest
Large locker + 4 extensions
£5,895
KeyNest
Medium locker + 4 extensions
£5,695
KeyNest
Small locker + 4 extensions
£5,495
KeyNest
Large locker + 3 extensions
£4,796
KeyNest
Medium locker + 3 extensions
£4,596
KeyNest
Small locker + 3 extensions
£4,396
KeyNest
Large locker + 2 extensions
£3,697
KeyNest
Medium locker + 2 extensions
£3,497
KeyNest
Small locker + 2 extensions
£3,297
KeyNest
Large locker + 1 extension
£2,598
KeyNest
Medium locker + 1 extension
£2,398
KeyNest
Small locker + 1 extension
£2,198
KeyNest
Large locker
£1,499
KeyNest
Medium locker
£1,299
KeyNest
Small locker
£1,099

Software

KeyCafe
KeyNest
Plans
KeyCafe 3 tiers: Lite, Premium, Business Pro
KeyNest 2 tiers: Standard, Premium
Price
KeyCafe £109-149/mo
KeyNest £89-119/mo
Unlimited keys & users
KeyCafe Yes
KeyNest Yes
Cellular connectivity
KeyCafe Yes
KeyNest Yes
Data imports/exports
KeyCafe Yes
KeyNest Yes
Installation and onboarding
KeyCafe Yes
KeyNest Yes
Time-restricted codes
KeyCafe Premium
KeyNest Yes
Key-level permissions
KeyCafe Premium
KeyNest Yes
Movement and activity history
KeyCafe Premium
KeyNest Yes
24/7 phone support
KeyCafe Business Pro
KeyNest Yes
API connection
KeyCafe Premium
KeyNest Premium
Staff badges
KeyCafe Premium
KeyNest Premium
Third-party integrations
KeyCafe Premium
KeyNest Premium
Custom logo
KeyCafe Business Pro
KeyNest Premium
Reservations
KeyCafe Business Pro
KeyNest Premium
Dedicated slot
KeyCafe Business Pro
KeyNest Premium
Testimonials icon

See what KeyNest customers are saying about the smart lockers

Hilton Hospitality & hotel management

"It's the smartest upgrade we've made to our operational security in years."

Robert Garvey,
Director of Safety & Security

XPO Logistics & fleet management

"Drivers had unrestricted access to all keys, often selecting vehicles based on personal preference rather than allocation" - a real risk, since the depot operates in an unmanned environment with no supervision to enforce it.

Giles Smith,
Transport Solutions General Manager

VolkerFitzpatrick Engineering & construction

"Keys were often left in different places without anyone knowing, which caused delays, confusion, and unnecessary stress for the team" - especially with 60+ staff and 40 vehicles moving across three separate compounds on a 24/7 shift pattern.

Karina Baciauskiene,
Logistics and Fleet Coordinator

KIS Autocentres Automotive

"The lockers removed the need for a front desk altogether." ... "We can't imagine expanding to new locations without them."

Paul Earthey,
Director

Landing Mid-term rentals

"We can set up custom access for different people depending on the job they need to do." ... "And collecting a key takes less than five seconds with the tap-and-go NFC system."

Christopher Cobb,
Access manager

Short-term rentals

"Amazing service and I use Keynest on all of my properties. It is great for automation, security and worth the money."

Zaur Badalov,
Property Manager

Aircraft Hotel & Event Small hotels

"Our guests can pick up their keys themselves, flexibly and easily - even outside of reception hours."

Nadja Tavarez,
Head of Hospitality

Metung Holiday park

"The more properties and bookings we took on, the more staff time was consumed by key management."

Kristy Penington,
Owner & Operator

Allsop Built-to-rent

"If it's user-friendly enough for some of our suppliers to use it, then it's got to be well-made."

Tom Lavington,
Asset Manager

Allsop testimonial Metung Holiday Villas testimonial Aircraft Hotel & Event testimonial Short-term rentals testimonial Landing testimonial KIS Autocentres testimonial VolkerFitzpatrick testimonial XPO Logistics testimonial Hilton testimonial

Where KeyNest has the advantage

KeyCafe
KeyNest
Global network
KeyCafe Focuses primarily on North American hubs, with fewer than 1,500 established global locations.
KeyNest Access a massive global infrastructure of 7,000+ locations, trusted by millions of global users.
Hardware capacity
KeyCafe Base units have limited capacity, often requiring additional paid expansion boxes to match volume.
KeyNest Store up to 39 keys in a single, compact unit without the need for expensive expansion modules.
Connectivity
KeyCafe Standard internal antennas may struggle for connectivity in underground or signal-shielded locations.
KeyNest A 30cm high-gain antenna ensures a stable signal in basements, garages, and thick-walled buildings.
Software integration
KeyCafe Integration options are available and may require custom API work on their end and an additional specific Business Pro subscription.
KeyNest Native, seamless integration with major platforms thanks to the most in-depth API on the market.
24/7 support
KeyCafe 24/7 phone support is restricted to high-tier plans, with lower tiers limited to chat and email.
KeyNest Multilingual 24/7 phone support is included for every user as standard on all plans.
Versatility from the get-go
KeyCafe Premium payment plan required to create user badges.
KeyNest Includes the capability to create user badges with the base plan.
Camera monitored
KeyCafe Includes a camera sensor.
KeyNest Users can easily install a doorbell camera with one of the internal USB sockets, with the capability to attach it to the locker itself.
VolkerFitzpatrick Landing
Hilton JLL
XPO Savills

of the 70,000 customers that have their keys handled by us

Two letting agents viewing KeyNest portal on the laptop
Contact icon

Book a demo call

Quick, no‑obligation call to give you an overview of this solution & answer any questions you may have.

Two letting agents viewing KeyNest portal on the laptop
Contact icon

Have a question? Get in touch

Looking for a custom solution? Need help? Fill out the form below and one of our friendly team members will get back to you.

FAQ icon

Frequently Asked Questions

Can't find what you're looking for? Reach out to our friendly support team by Chat or give us a ring on 0203 633 4599

Do I need an app?

No. Guests and drivers can collect keys using a simple screen code or a user badge.

Is it secure?

Yes. Our lockers are built from automotive-grade galvanised steel with tamper-resistant locks.

Can it work offline?

Yes. If there’s a power outage and the internet is down, and 4G can’t be detected via the SIM, KeyNest can generate two types of codes:

  • Master code — gives access to all key slots
  • Individual code — gives access to a single slot

How many keys can I hold?

We offer S, M, and L sizes. Our L Locker holds 39 keys in a single sleek unit, and can be extended to hold hundreds more.

What if I move locations?

KeyNest Lockers are plug-and-play. Simply unbolt the locker from the backplate, move it to your new site, and plug it in.

Is it compatible with my existing staff fob?

Most likely, yes — but please double-check with your sales rep.

What is the lead time?

It depends on where you’re located, but on average it’s 5–7 days.

Are KeyNest Lockers IP rated?

Some of our KeyNest Lockers are IP rated — please double-check with your sales rep.