Historic Centre Of Florence Bans Airbnbs And Short-Term Rentals

Florence, the iconic capital of Italy’s Tuscany region, renowned for its art, architecture, and history, has taken a significant step in regulating its holiday rentals imposing rental ban on new short-term holiday rentals since June of 2023. In response to rising housing concerns, the city has introduced stricter measures aimed at curbing the impact of Airbnb and similar platforms. This move comes as a growing number of residents and local authorities express concerns about affordability, overcrowding and the preservation of unique cultural heritage in Florence. 

Short-term rentals have been both a blessing and a curse—while they boost tourism, they have also displaced long-term residents. The new regulations are designed to strike a balance between promoting tourism and safeguarding the city's reduction of housing stock. The approach in Florence reflects a broader trend in Europe, where cities are grappling with the consequences of unregulated short-term rentals. For hosts and guests alike, understanding these changes is crucial to navigating the evolving landscape of short-term accommodations maintaining Florence historic atmosphere. 

This article delves into the specifics of new policies in Florence, their implications, and what they mean for the future of Airbnb and other platforms in this historic city.

1. Overview Of Florence’s New Short-Term Rental Regulations

The Italian government in Florence has seen its housing depleted by short-term rentals and has introduced sweeping regulations to address housing crisis in Italy exacerbated by short-term rentals in its historic Italian city. These measures  for rentals in the same city aim to reduce the strain on local communities while preserving cultural and historical integrity of Florence. 

Rentals in Florence were listed before June 2023 can still be allowed to operate with new laws and regulations in placed.

• Registration requirement: Hosts in listing platforms such as Airbnb would need to register their properties with local authorities.

• Cap on rental days: Limits imposed on the number of days a property can be rented annually.

• Restricted zones: Certain areas, particularly the historic center, have stricter rules or outright bans.

• Tax obligations: Enhanced enforcement of tax reporting and compliance.

• Fines for non-compliance: Hefty penalties for those who violate the new regulations.

• Support for long-term rentals: Incentives for landlords to prioritize long-term leases over short-term lets.

2. Impact On Airbnb Hosts In Florence

The new regulations have introduced significant challenges for hosts and landlords of existing short-term lets in Florence. Many are now grappling with how to adapt their business models to comply with the city’s stricter rules.

• Increased paperwork: Hosts must navigate the registration process and keep records up to date.

• Reduced earnings: Limits on how long short-term rental can be rented in days and higher taxes cut into profits on attempt to make more homes available for locals.

• Fewer available properties: Hosts in restricted zones face tougher regulations for homes rented out for tourism purposes and new owners would also be restricted from operating as a holiday let.

• Increased operational costs: Compliance measures add to the cost of managing properties in historic city centres and municipalities...

• Shift to long-term leasing: Many hosts having listed on short-let platforms are considering transitioning to long-term rentals.

• Legal risks: Non-compliance could lead to hefty fines and legal challenges on the rental properties.

3. What This Means For Tourists Visiting Florence

Tourists planning a trip to one of Italy's most popular tourist destination may find it more challenging to secure affordable and convenient because of the crackdown on short-term rental accommodations. It will result of complaining about finding a right stay for tourist as the city aims to have 70 per cent of houses residential properties rented instead.

However, these changes are aimed at creating a more sustainable tourism experience as a Unesco world heritage site and affordable housing for residents.

• Fewer holiday-let options: A reduced number of short-term rentals in prime locations especially on city's historic center.

• Higher prices: Limited supply may drive up costs for available properties especially on municipalities with a high density of tourists.

• Focus on licensed rentals: Travelers should book properties that comply with local regulations.

• Greater emphasis on hotels: Hotels may see an increase in bookings as rental options dwindle.

• Cultural preservation: Reduced tourist overcrowding in the historic center.

• Transparency in pricing: Compliance ensures guests pay fair prices and taxes.

4. Florence Approach Compared To Other European Cities

Florence is not alone in its efforts to regulate short-term rentals. Across Europe, cities are implementing various measures to address similar challenges, providing valuable insights into global trends.

• Paris: Limits on rental days and mandatory registration for hosts.

• Amsterdam: Strict caps on short-term rental permits.

• Barcelona: Bans on short-term rentals in certain neighborhoods.

• Berlin: Fines for illegal short-term rentals and restrictions on property use.

• Venice: Special taxes on short-term rentals in tourist-heavy areas.

• Lisbon: Incentives for long-term leases and limits on new short-term rental licenses.

5. How Florence’s Regulations Preserve Cultural Heritage

While regulations go beyond housing concerns in Florence ; they aim to protect the city’s cultural and historical legacy. By managing cultural travel more sustainably, the Tuscan city seeks to maintain its unique charm and identity.

• Reduced overcrowding: Fewer tourists in Florence relying on hotels.

• Preservation of housing: Ensuring locals can continue to live in the city.

• Support for local businesses: Encouraging tourists to explore lesser-known areas.

• Protection of historical sites: Less wear and tear on iconic landmarks.

• Community well-being: Balancing cultural travel with residents’ quality of life.

• Sustainable cultural travel model: Ensuring Florence remains a desirable destination for future generations.

6. Tips For Hosts To Adapt To New Rules

Navigating new regulations in Florence can be challenging for hosts, but with the right strategies, they can adapt and thrive in the evolving market.

• Stay informed: Keep up-to-date with the latest regulatory changes.

• Register your property: Ensure compliance by completing the registration process.

• Explore long-term rental options: Consider switching to long-term leases.

• Enhance guest experiences: Focus on quality over quantity to attract bookings.

• Collaborate with local authorities: Work with officials to ensure compliance.

• Invest in legal advice: Seek professional guidance to navigate complex rules.

Adapting To Florence’s Evolving Short-Term Rental Landscape

The crackdown on Airbnbs and short-term rentals in Florence, Italy marks a turning point for both hosts and guests. The regulations aim to address pressing housing concerns while preserving the city’s cultural and historical identity. For hosts, adapting to these changes requires diligence, creativity, and a willingness to embrace long-term rental models. 

Tourists, too, must navigate a shifting landscape with fewer short-term rental options but a more sustainable and authentic travel experience. By balancing cultural travel with the needs of residents, Florence is setting an example for other cities facing similar challenges. Hosts who stay informed and proactive can still find opportunities to thrive under the new rules. Travelers, meanwhile, can enjoy a more enriching and less crowded experience in this iconic city.

Florence’s approach serves as a reminder of the importance of sustainable tourism for the benefit of all stakeholders. Embracing these changes is not only necessary but also an opportunity to create a more harmonious relationship between tourism and local communities.

About Us: KeyNest

KeyNest offers you a convenient service for storing and exchanging your property keys. You can drop off a key at any of the 7,000+ locations in our network, so there’s one such Point located next to your property. 

Guests, cleaners or contractors can then collect the key securely from a KeyNest Point or KeyNest Locker  which is usually open 24/7. You'll be notified each time the key is picked up or returned, and you can even customize check-in and check-out times. By leveraging technology and a global network of locations, KeyNest continues to redefine property management, offering solutions tailored to meet the evolving needs of the rental market..

KeyNest has an ever-expanding global network of locations located just minutes from your property. To find out more you can contact us. 

Neil Beltran 21 January 2025